Ranking
View Poll Results: Led Zeppelin or Pink Floyd?
Led Zeppelin
38 Votes / 50.00%
Pink Floyd
38 Votes / 50.00%
Voters: 76. You may not vote on this poll
View Poll Results

It feels unfair for me to choose
5:13 PM - vasp: everybody's nuts is so good
[00:18:38] <&vespesi3n> you should see when i swallow
[21:49:37] <&vespesi3n> >my mouth when
[21:49:43] <&vespesi3n> >my tastebuds when
Just look at your usertitle.
i have a totally post modern tattoo of a scalene triangle.
<DeadorK> fair maiden
<DeadorK> if the cum is going to be in your mouth
<DeadorK> it shall be in mine as well
good point.
5:13 PM - vasp: everybody's nuts is so good
[00:18:38] <&vespesi3n> you should see when i swallow
[21:49:37] <&vespesi3n> >my mouth when
[21:49:43] <&vespesi3n> >my tastebuds when
Pink Floyd FTW!!
David guilmour is the greatest guitar player in the world for me....
"Be obscure clearly."
The thing is that the average Pink Floyd song is simply better than the average Led Zeppelin song... But Led Zeppelin has more great songs in total.

That's why it's so difficult to pick between the two.

What one could do is look at it this way.

Robert Plant > Roger Waters/David Gilmour (Vocals)
John Bonham > Nick Mason (Percussion)
Jimmy Page = David Gilmour (Guitar)
John Paul Jones < Roger Waters (Bass)

So who is to decide?
Originally Posted by Advancius View Post
Floyd are the masters of psychedelic rock, Zeppelin the masters of hard rock.

Incomparable.

He has an excellent point.
I have left Toribash, but will drop in occasionally on the forums and IRC. Still in Sigma.
Originally Posted by Drummer View Post
He has an excellent point.

Except that his point is the very reason we seek to compare them, not just to determine the greater band, but to determine the greater genre.