it see nice us but try to give the hidden blade a little visibler maybe a reflection effect

Nice singture 8.5/10

Horrible flow, centered focal, poor lighting and really, really bad smudging. The stock is nice, but the things you did to it aren't. You still have a long way to go before you can call these proper signatures.

3/10

I would suggest looking at the GFX Hall of Fame for some idea of what good flow, lighting and focal placement look like.