ooo, I like the way that's turning out

I don't know how I feel about the pupils being white however rather than black, but the shadow/shading is basically what I was after.

I could make the pupils black with a white outline so you could still see them?

black with depth? Can we make them a bit larger aswell?

SOunds good

can the center of the eye stand out from the shadows without being white at all?

could you explain a bit more what you mean by depth

I dont think that is possible without another color because for it to be seen there needs to be contrast between the pupil and the black but i will see what I can do

white and black

More like a black hole than straight up black swirl. I don't see any depth

wip4

Too wide. You can refer back to the previous image. Can we make the mouth and eyes like: O_O and :O with a lot of work just crammed in them?

So like wip 2 with a circular mouth