Originally Posted by Parrot

I disagree with the random mods bit. However, it does make sense.

I believe that you should have the ranking system base off of this premise:

Ranks for Grappling
Ranks for Striking
Ranks for Kicking
etc.

Each of these ranking categories come with its own playlist of mods. I definitely believe this would be a much better system to have. Comments?

Originally Posted by cowmeat

Because a mod is made with something in mind doesn't mean the outcome always reflects that something..... if you didn't know this already.


Tk is 100% less viable. With 100DM, the chance for random DM's is much higher.


Some of my reasoning here:


#1 The combination of low DM and DQ floor creates games where a single random DM decides games where as in erthtk you have to work for the DQ win.

#2 The lower gravity makes snapkicks way more viable and lowers the need for good balance = less skill

#3 Anecdotal: My highest winstreak in erthtk is around 30 in public (vs public randoms) where as it's around 15 in normal TK. It's way harder to streak in vanilla TK, because the mod is more random and less skill based.

#4 Running in erthtk is super hard. In normal TK, super easy. You have to work for the point victory.

#5 self damage encourages good form and proper attacks while in normal TK you can flail without thinking if you choose to do so.

Literally all of the skill factors that are in normal TK are in ERTHTK while it removes a lot of normal TKs randomness.

Originally Posted by BlueEvil

true

well you can avoid those "randomness" in tk if you're good enuf, and just becuz you only did a 15 streak in tk doesnt have to mean that tk is more skillless, that more means that your skills are lower than in erthtk

lets better say erthtkv2 is more comfortable/reasonable for the mod making match

____________

apart from that, it would be cool if you can play ranked by choosing a mod
and random ranked match making
like you get more/lose more elo points if you choose random
and that ppl can stay by 1 mod if the feel like to play

Originally Posted by Dare

This idea of having a pool/group is great. Like what greenblits said too. In addition this idea will greatly distinguish the pros, good players, average players , noobs, new players, so on and so forth. It will make the less skilled players to practice even harder to get to the top. In addition though this is a perfect idea. The one problem is finding out what the top players will do in the final pool with the elite players. They may think this is a great idea for a bit but then break off of tb since they will think they have made it too the top. So we have to think of an idea to counter that but otherwise for the lower tiers it's perfect in my opinion.

Originally Posted by greenblits

I don't think you know who cowmeat is




Like clash of clans did, they added more ranks later in the game. But the main thing we need is more players. Having an icon for what tier you're in would also be fun to have, bringing a sentiment of accomplishment.

Originally Posted by FistofLife

Esports talk

Originally Posted by cowmeat

Firstly, no game becomes an e-sport without a massive casual player base.
We have a super small player base. Trying to make TB an "esport" is never going to happen.

I certainly want some competitiveness to the game but let's not go down the Esport discussion path. There are more than enough reasons why TB will never be an esport within the game itself not even talking about the playerbase.

The reason why TB doesn't keep players isn't because "People want esports", it's because of the nature of this game. Only a few people want to grind a game like this enough to be so good at it that it starts to be viable to compete in.
A game where you have to play a thousand games before there is enough skill involved to even have a resemblance of competition, is a bit hard to make into a popular one.

It's an old game that will die almost completely in the next few years. Let's keep making it better and implement these good ideas. But let's also not have grand delusions of bringing thousands of people into the game because of a good matchmaking system.

Originally Posted by cowmeat

Firstly, no game becomes an e-sport without a massive casual player base.
We have a super small player base. Trying to make TB an "esport" is never going to happen.

I certainly want some competitiveness to the game but let's not go down the Esport discussion path. There are more than enough reasons why TB will never be an esport within the game itself not even talking about the playerbase.

The reason why TB doesn't keep players isn't because "People want esports", it's because of the nature of this game. Only a few people want to grind a game like this enough to be so good at it that it starts to be viable to compete in.
A game where you have to play a thousand games before there is enough skill involved to even have a resemblance of competition, is a bit hard to make into a popular one.

It's an old game that will die almost completely in the next few years. Let's keep making it better and implement these good ideas. But let's also not have grand delusions of bringing thousands of people into the game because of a good matchmaking system.