They seem to be a lame excuse for a game reviewing "group".
The girl pisses me off because she tries to find some ridiculously complex reason to enjoy or not enjoy both games. "...you have to be a fun person for the game [Toribash] to be fun." What? I agree that a game is only as fun as you make it but for a game to rely completely on the personality of the player is a farce.
I think the reviews are okay, but not nearly of the quality I would expect from 1UP.
EDIT: Maybe if they set the language of Makibishi Comic to English they would know what the fuck they're supposed to be doing in the game. :P