Crystalman's replay is a 19 frame limb removal. The head shouldn't count. Also, I don't think Crystal's should even count since he went from the knees down.

I believe this to be 30 frames...

That is better since it takes from the leg down.

What If I decide elbows and knees ONLY
Im pretty sure I have the fastest elbows and knees replay, thats why hampa put it In the replays directory In game.
The replay is called Tear limbs.
I can still edit it and make it 5 frames faster.

Then the limbs aren't actually removed, only part of them is.
If you were to remove all of a mans limbs IRL (Not saying that you should!), you
wouldn't just remove his elbows and knees, am i right?

True, I would have to Rip his head off first.

>_>

If the stumps of his arms and legs still are attached to his body, then
the limbs aren't removed entirely. He would still be able to move them if
he wasn't dead already.

I concur.

Like I said from the start for the most part....

My bad, I read what you said wrong and thought you said it should be counted.