Have you tried reinstalling the game?
if you have try verifying the games cache. to do so right click toribash in your steam library and click properties then click local files then from there click Verify game integrity and it will start verifying
if that doesn't work go check on your actual replays folder and see if you have it duplicated that happened in one of my earlier versions. and if you don't know how to check your replays folder go to toribash in the steam library right click it then click properties then from there click local files then browse local files.
Last edited by Miyako; Jun 25, 2014 at 09:53 AM.