I still haven't seen the replays yet (still shopping for clothes for my graduation this friday). However, going off of what others have been saying, I think my opinion should still be said. Keep in mind that this may change once I see the replays myself.
When I applied for Vector, I got somewhat of the same response from people. "Close, but not close enough." Compared to my movement now, back then I was stiff beyond belief and the only thing going for me was my balance (on ground and in air). However, I still got in with a replay that I believe still didnt show my full potential. Either way, I got into Vector because of it (i posted a better replay afterwards, which made me feel better •u•) What I'm hearing from everyone really just reminded me of when I applied. I was pretty much a beginner replaymaker that only had a good sense of balance and tori manipulation (not uke, that's different). I was a one trick pony, only being able to mas. Yet, even though I only knew one thing, I still got in. I improved the longer I stayed here, and it's gotten me to where I am now. So I'm hoping that Keshoi gets to have the same experience. Currently I'm
neutral about this, but I'm leaning towards a yes. Hopefully your replays make me scream yes