The first replay is made of pretty basic routines, and although it looks fine it's not very refined. Your right knee changes from holding to contracting multiple times throughout the opener for no apparent reason, and your pecs don't work together with the chest for the spins, the chest is almost always delayed. Dms are alright. Your decision to grab immediately after the big swing hit completely killed its perceived force, but hoenstly I think it's a matter of taste. The skeet is in my opinion not worth throwing yourself off balance and forcing a questionable transition to the pose.
Second replay has more interesting movements. The first kick is an exception, everything is stiff except for the kicking leg and the contracting elbow, if anything it made it harder for you. If you pause around frame 135 it's very easy to see how your pecs are swinging much earlier than your chest and consequently making your spins weaker. I'm a fan of the front flip to pose.
Obviously not a huge fan of the repeating opener in the last replay, that aside the movement looks somewhat lazy. Many readjustments and tweaks that should have been avoided by editing earlier, such as your right hand suddenly reaching for the floor at 480, and lowering your arm at 420 after letting it drift too far up. Although your didn't take damage, the manipulation wasn't particularly pretty or powerful, I don't think the trade was worth it. I did like the boomhit punch, pretty stylish and clean.
I'd say keep refining your movement, and think slightly ahead, how will this movement affect my ability to kick/jump/etc later.., and set up your arms and legs for kicks or pushing off the floor early so you don't have to prepare everything very late.
This is a secondary and very subjective point, but I think having your turnframes very low and using shift+space too much gives you a poor perception of movement. Movements that might not fit in look more acceptable because you're essentially making everything in slow motion.
My vote is a no, but as always hope to see another app later on. As for your previous apps, I don't particularly recall them, but anyone who keeps at it will eventually be cool enough to join.
Last edited by pusga; Oct 4, 2019 at 04:48 PM.