Alright, after installation when I first gotten toribash, I got sick of the clutter of replays that were in the replay folder, (Which came with the game), I was still a little interested in them, so I made a folder in the replays folder, for the replays that came with the game, so It would seperate my replays, and the replays that came with the game. But in doing so, somehow, my replays wouldn't show up in the replay directory, but they would show up in game list. So hoping it would fix the problem, I deleted all the replays that weren't mine and came with the game. And now, when I want new replays, I'll save them and they still show up in the game list, when playing toribash, but in the program files directory for replays, they aren't to be found.
That help? It's a little complex, for something simple lol.