Originally Posted by Ele

mwah, it's a 'debate' (it's an inquiry) about the standards of what it takes to be a legendary clan

Turns out there is no standard. No formalised criteria. Is all case-by-case. Which is fine (some things should be handled on a case-by-case basis), but it just means that there's no 'formula' for what it takes to be legendary, therefore, no way to really reverse-engineer why Inq didn't get legendary

In the process of attempting to reverse-engineer, the (stated) reasons why other clans achieved legendary status were examined and NO was one of them

Hope that cleared things up

Originally Posted by mwah

what makes anything legendary? remarkable enough to be famous

so i guess you have to ask what makes inq remarkable in this community?

Originally Posted by RAAAGE

If you want an easy answer, it’s because “torilegends” are a circlejerk lmao

Originally Posted by basic

what makes it remarkable come on answer the question

Originally Posted by Liquidoom

I really didn't want to have to post on this thread, but I feel like I pretty much everything I can bring to the table has not been posted yet. Before I give my two cents, let me start off by stating that the overall tone in this thread has been at times very negative, passive-aggressive or straigth up disrespectful and going forward I hope that behaviour stops. Now let's get to it.




I'll keep this short, but notably:


- Winners of the 2008 Clan League
- Very, very old clan (it was alive for more than 10 years, which blows my mind when you compare with the average lifetime of a clan)

- Filled with many impactful members of the community throughout its lifespan (for example, the clan currently has 4 legendary members (Chris, Fnugget, Warhero and Hagan), many ex-staff members (Liquidoom (myself), Lightningkid, Huck, Uric, eightah, Lortexx, zwouter, Link, Aracoon, Nerti, HolyButler, Zoro, sham, Tim, Yiazmat and probably a few more).

I'm sure that older [i] members can add more to the list, but just with what I posted, you can clearly see that inquisition isn't your typical clan and it stands out when you compare it with the average official clan. It served as a pillar of the community throughout its lifetime because it was a clan of longstanding comprised of many members which had a lasting impact on the game or which helped shape it in the game we love. In my humble opinion, it should of been made legendary.


EDIT: The formatting seems to be all over the place for some reason, despite being clean in the text editor. Bug with the new forums?

Originally Posted by Greg

Nice twist. A better question would be is, “what makes inq remarkable as a clan?” since you know, it’s a clan. Frankly, that’s a lot, Mwah. Just the the paper achievements alone are great.
-----
You make it sound like the only thing that matters are making changes and being staff.