Has somebody ever made a compilation of all default replays of every toribash version over the years?
If so, I would love to have that. I really want to see those nostalgic replays once again.

Rapid threads, not Discussion material.

I would suggest asking Orko, or making a post on ORMO's nuclear rainbow thread of mauling doom. I don't think a proper compilation exists, but he might have the different versions of the game to check.