I'm presenting the obvious flaws in the idea. I don't hate the idea, there have been ones that are plenty worse, but there's no reason to not present a counterargument to each and every idea. As the lmod here I figure I may as well play Devil's advocate.
I still stand by my belief that I don't think an upstanding member would need to pay for an unban (if it's permanent there's usually a good reason), but it still puts money in Nabi's pocket so I suppose the damage it could cause isn't all bad.