Originally Posted by Faint
like gynx said, we don't quantify the amount of posts you have in your board, we quantify how many members have posted, or have displayed levels of activity. if the activity is simply you, and 1 or 2 other clan members posting 5 or 6 times a day, the clan will fail the check, and your clan isn't the only one. it's only fair to do it that way because if a clan has 30 members and 2 of them are active, how can that clan be deemed active in any fashion? it should be apparent that a clan with 10 members posting every week or so, or have been in-game or on irc recently would be deemed active while a clan with 2 active members would fail; i guess i'm misunderstanding where this isn't apparent, though it's been explained several times. none of you had any problems with the ways we did our checks until it started affecting your clan, and it's the same for every clan in your position. we have so much information regarding our checks that has been made publicly visible that i don't understand where the shock is coming from when we roll out these checks; it's like you guys think we are directly targeting clans or being biased in our checks.
We always had the impression that we only accept skilled players with enough of a brain to hold a conversation with, hence why we currently only have 16 members. Out of these 16, 6 have posted in the recent time which is ok in my opinion considering that this game hasnt changed in 9 years and we all have lives.
Originally Posted by Faint
irc activity
Why would this qualify as activity, its not ingame and its not on the forums. No one would ever see the activity if you don't actually go in irc and enter their channel and check for yourself. This just seems like an excuse to give some clans a free pass. We got a skype group, does that work? How about carrier pigeons?
Anyway, if its gonna make this community so much better its fine with me.
SP replays | [Urban] | MP replays
Originally Posted by leilak
We always had the impression that we only accept skilled players with enough of a brain to hold a conversation with, hence why we currently only have 16 members. Out of these 16, 6 have posted in the recent time which is ok in my opinion considering that this game hasnt changed in 9 years and we all have lives.
Why would this qualify as activity, its not ingame and its not on the forums. No one would ever see the activity if you don't actually go in irc and enter their channel and check for yourself. This just seems like an excuse to give some clans a free pass. We got a skype group, does that work? How about carrier pigeons?
Anyway, if its gonna make this community so much better its fine with me.
As of the activity check there was not 6 active members, of course now that you've failed the check & used other social channels to arouse a response there are more members "active" when in reality they're not active at all. We've been monitoring every clan for a while now, Urban hasn't been 6 members strong in a week for a long time (at least on Toribash). Also, having less members total (like we suggest) makes it easier to pass a test - the fact you failed by having as little as 16 when other clans are passing with 50 (handily, too) should give you some sort of indication as to just how inactive you guys are.
Originally Posted by AlphaN00b
um how about if we just do a poll for Urban to keep going alive or die?
That's not something that is open for discussion. The facts are on the table, we'll review them and see if there's any case whereby we can justify the keeping of Urban but there will be no public poll or discussion regarding the survival of Urban that will hold any definitive results (although you are welcome to talk about it here like we are currently).
Last edited by Gynx; Apr 19, 2015 at 06:00 PM.
collect snots from the nose
Is there a public thread that explains how deleting clans that have been around for a long time benefits toribash? or at least how does it
A dueler is only a good as his finest lift.
I love many people on this forum such as ...
Uric|Internet|Stellar|Wesley|Boonana|AJ|FireBolty|iRookie|Brucia|Kristis133|Liquidoom|Lightningkid
[type=noob]monk[noob]
I respect...[type=noob]monk[noob]
Thanks Gynx you made my day with such arguments about our "failed activity".
In my opinion no need to raise the activity of the clan or remove it which has already become a part of history or so. If some pretty old clans are threatened removal so actually it looks like a "deleting some part of history" and that's just stupid.
Most of us are busy nowadays and that's not a reason to kick them out from the clan, thereby trying to pass some kind of test.. Actually too stupid
My english sux but w\e
although EJM more sux than my english
In my opinion no need to raise the activity of the clan or remove it which has already become a part of history or so. If some pretty old clans are threatened removal so actually it looks like a "deleting some part of history" and that's just stupid.
Originally Posted by Gynx
...Also, having less members total (like we suggest) makes it easier to pass a test)...
Most of us are busy nowadays and that's not a reason to kick them out from the clan, thereby trying to pass some kind of test.. Actually too stupid
My english sux but w\e
although EJM more sux than my english
Last edited by Samopal; Apr 20, 2015 at 12:00 AM.
